Tue May 19 New York (Lake Erie) & Ohio Storm
May 19 alley-wide storm -- 0.9" in 12hrs, Buffalo Creek blew out, Cazenovia Creek fishable Thursday.
Meteorological Analysis
A major storm system rolled through the Steelhead Alley region starting on Tuesday, May 19, 2026 and lasting until Tuesday, May 19, 2026. The storm was active for approximately 12 hours, dumping a maximum of 0.90" of rain across affected zones. Geographically, the weather system impacted the New York (Lake Erie), Ohio regions, causing rapid water-level rises on multiple tributaries.
Gauges recorded significant river responses, particularly along Ashtabula River (peaking at 131 CFS), Conneaut Creek (peaking at 282 CFS), Vermilion River @ Vermilion (peaking at 463 CFS), Cuyahoga River @ Independence (peaking at 747 CFS), Brandy Run near Girard (peaking at 24 CFS), Cattaraugus Creek (peaking at 685 CFS), Chautauqua Creek (peaking at 35 CFS), Eighteen Mile Creek (peaking at 69 CFS), Huron River (peaking at 419 CFS), Black River (peaking at 241 CFS), Euclid Creek (peaking at 90 CFS), Canadaway Creek (peaking at 165 CFS), Silver Creek (peaking at 27 CFS), Buffalo Creek (peaking at 133 CFS), Cazenovia Creek (peaking at 292 CFS). Angling conditions deteriorated quickly during the peak flow periods, leading to temporary washouts. Gaging stations monitored the recovery times as flows began returning to their baselines, mapping out the best windows for fishermen to get back on the water.
From a weather prediction standpoint, the NWS forecasts for this event received an aggregate score card grade of 'B'. Gaging observations were matched against NWS precipitation models to assess the forecasting margins, highlighting the variance in local rainfall amounts across the lake shores.
Tributary Response & Recovery
Ashtabula River
- Pre-Storm Flow
- N/A
- Observed Peak
- 131 CFS
- Peak Time
- May 19, 01:15
Conneaut Creek
- Pre-Storm Flow
- 140 CFS
- Observed Peak
- 282 CFS
- Peak Time
- May 21, 14:00
- Baseline Return
- May 22, 05:00
Vermilion River @ Vermilion
- Pre-Storm Flow
- 115 CFS
- Observed Peak
- 463 CFS
- Peak Time
- May 21, 08:00
- Recovers By
- May 22, 05:00
Cuyahoga River @ Independence
- Pre-Storm Flow
- N/A
- Observed Peak
- 747 CFS
- Peak Time
- May 19, 01:00
Brandy Run near Girard
- Pre-Storm Flow
- 4 CFS
- Observed Peak
- 24 CFS
- Peak Time
- May 20, 05:00
- Baseline Return
- May 20, 18:00
Cattaraugus Creek
- Pre-Storm Flow
- N/A
- Observed Peak
- 685 CFS
- Peak Time
- May 19, 01:00
Chautauqua Creek
- Pre-Storm Flow
- N/A
- Observed Peak
- 35 CFS
- Peak Time
- May 19, 01:00
Eighteen Mile Creek
- Pre-Storm Flow
- N/A
- Observed Peak
- 69 CFS
- Peak Time
- May 19, 01:00
Huron River
- Pre-Storm Flow
- 127 CFS
- Observed Peak
- 419 CFS
- Peak Time
- May 21, 06:00
- Baseline Return
- May 22, 14:00
Black River
- Pre-Storm Flow
- 87 CFS
- Observed Peak
- 241 CFS
- Peak Time
- May 22, 07:00
Euclid Creek
- Pre-Storm Flow
- 10 CFS
- Observed Peak
- 90 CFS
- Peak Time
- May 20, 05:00
- Baseline Return
- May 20, 20:00
Canadaway Creek
- Pre-Storm Flow
- 43 CFS
- Observed Peak
- 165 CFS
- Peak Time
- May 20, 08:00
- Baseline Return
- May 21, 01:00
Silver Creek
- Pre-Storm Flow
- N/A
- Observed Peak
- 27 CFS
- Peak Time
- May 19, 01:00
Buffalo Creek
- Pre-Storm Flow
- N/A
- Observed Peak
- 133 CFS
- Peak Time
- May 19, 01:00
Cazenovia Creek
- Pre-Storm Flow
- 172 CFS
- Observed Peak
- 292 CFS
- Peak Time
- May 20, 18:00
- Recovers By
- May 21, 06:00
- Baseline Return
- May 21, 02:00
Fishing Guide & Tactics
Looking for advice on how to target steelhead on these rivers when they are recovering from a storm? Check out our master guides: